Stranded students rescued by Brown County cooperation 4-H Teen Ambassador Dunning attends SHOT Show Veterans Service Commission invites veterans to seek help with benefits Unemployment rate rises in Brown County Pick a Lollipop, help a dog A season to remember G-Men hit the field for first baseball scrimmage Eastern’s Rigdon, Purdy earn AP SE District Div. III honors New blocking, kicking rules address risk minimization in high school football Judy A Schneider James M Darnell Lawanda R Truesdell Paul E Grisham Arrelous R Rowland Dennis E Stivers David M Daniels Fayetteville man is charged with child porn April 1st Grand Opening for Jacob’s Ladder Resale Boutique in Georgetown Talent Show auditions at Gaslight Theatre Nine indicted by county grand jury Vietnam Veteran’s Memorial Wall visit coming next May to BC Fairgrounds In it to win it! Bronco wrestlers end season on successful note Eastern’s Hopkins finishes 5th in long jump at OATCCC State Indoor Track and Field Meet SBAAC awards academic all-stars, winning teams Marvin D Atkin Beverly S Flatt Jessie M Sanders Leroy Deck Sr Jody A Towler Sherman E Young Kenneth C Burton Varnau’s face second defamation suit Attorney General to visit Georgetown schools Clermont County GOP hosts Wenstrup, DeWine at dinner Fatal car crash in Adams County BC Chamber welcomes new Cricket Wireless store to Mt. Orab Aberdeen Council approves 2017 budget Royce K Zimmerman Lady Warriors advance to Elite 8 SBAAC awards boys basketball all-stars SBAAC girls basketball all-stars take home awards SHAC Winter Sports Awards Banquet set for March 12 Altman claims 170-pound district title Sirkka L Buller Arthur C Schneider Lowell G Neal Virginia M Schirmer Connie S Darling Harold L Purdin Terry E Frye Lucille Schumacher Lady Warriors roll to district finals Broncos take care of business to claim sectional crown G-Men upset MVCA to earn berth sectional finals WBHS JROTC Rifle Team competes at Camp Perry Lady Rockets finish 12-12 Season reaches end for Rockets Eugene D Ring Two indicted on major drug charges Two charged with home invasion Cincinnati airport expanding services, lowering prices in effort to compete Two sentenced in common pleas court Georgetown man hurt in car crash Robert G Miller Linda M Howland Robert E McKinney Mildred J Hodges Farrel L Amiott Patricia Brown Rick L Dye Mary E Nagel Betty Ratliff Broncos claim SBAAC wrestling title Broncos pull ahead for win over G-Men in SBAAC Tourney Ripley boys wrap up regular season with win at Lynchburg Eastern girls are sectional champs Anderson pleads not guilty to battery charge Some county offices to change locations Fayetteville prepares for Traveling Vietnam Memorial Wall HealthSource hosts Chamber of Commerce meeting Five sentenced in Brown County Common Pleas Court June Howser Marguerite A Fender Timothy D Harris Jay R Purdy Robin S Godwin Marc A Wachter Chester W Eyre Warriors blast past the G-Men, 61-40 Rockets performing well heading into post-season tournament play Lady Warriors bring home the Gold with perfect 13-0 finish in SHAC Western Brown Junior High wrestling team wraps up successful season Rockets fall victim to ‘Pack’ attack Broncos suffer heartbreaking loss to Mentor Lake Catholic in state quarterfinals Adult Education Center coming to county ‘Senior Playground’ moving forward at Georgetown park Brown County 4-H kicks off another year Eastern Middle School celebrates “Kindness Week” Billie L Shoemaker

Little granted summary judgment

A U.S. District Court judge in the Southern District of Ohio, Eastern Division granted summary judgment to Brown County Prosecutor Jessica Little in a court case involving five former employees of the Ohio Department of Natural Resources.

Judge Gregory L. Frost concluded in his decision on June 4 that “Little is absolutely immune from liability for any of the alleged misconduct” from the plaintiffs in the $2 million lawsuit against her, the office of the Brown County Prosecutor, and other members of the Ohio Inspector General’s office and ODNR.

“In this case five current and former ODNR employees alleged that Prosecutor Little fabricated evidence and subjected them to a malicious prosecution among other meritless claims,” a statement from the Brown County Prosecutor’s Office read. “Prosecutor Little complied with all professional obligations relative to Plaintiffs. Accordingly, she vigorously defended herself against their meritless claims. Prosecutor Little presented evidence that she acted within the scope of her prosecutorial duties at all times.

“As a result, Prosecutor Little was granted summary judgment by United States District Court Judge Gregory L. Frost. This decision illustrates Prosecutor Little’s unwavering commitment to fulfilling her prosecutorial duties in the service of Brown County and the State of Ohio.”

The plaintiffs in the case, Randy Miller, James Lehman, Michele Ward-Tackett, David Graham, and Todd Haines. Graham was the ODNR Division of Wildlife Chief, Miller was the Assistant Chief, Ward-Tackett was a Human Resource Manager, Lehman was a Law Enforcement Executive Administrator, and Haines was a District Manager.

The case revolves around an incident in 2006 when former Brown County DOW wildlife officer Alan Wright helped a friend, who was a wildlife officer in South Carolina, obtain an in-state hunting license by listing Wright’s address as the friend’s home address. That enabled the friend to only have to pay $19 instead of the non-resident fee of $125.

The Ohio Office of the Inspector General found out about the misconduct in 2009 and ordered the then-head of ODNR Sean Logan to conduct an investigation. Logan reported back that an investigation had already been completed. Instead of reporting the misconduct to the ODNR director and the ODNR’s legal counsel, the five plaintiffs decided to handle the possible crime internally, issuing Wright a “verbal reprimand.”

The OIG ordered a new investigation, and in March 2010, they filed a report, coming to the conclusion that not only did Wright commit a crime but that the five plaintiffs did not follow ODNR policies to report the crime.

One month later, a Brown County grand jury indicted each of the five plaintiffs on one count of obstruction of justice and one count complicity in obstructing justice, both fifth-degree felonies.

The indictment caused the quintet to be placed on indefinite administrative leave, even though they were innocent until proven guilty.

The case against the plaintiffs was eventually dismissed after the plaintiffs moved to suppress their statements they made to then-OIG deputy director Ron Nichols. The Brown County Court of Common Pleas ruled in their favor, but an appeals court overturned that decision. But then an appeal to the Ohio Supreme Court in 2013 ruled again in the plaintiff’s favor, leading to Little to dismiss the case. The five plaintiffs originally pleaded not guilty to the charges.

Despite the decision, Graham was fired, Miller and Lehman were forced to resign, and Ward-Tackett and Haines were re-assigned.

In response, the plaintiffs filed a counter-law suit against Little, the BCPO, the OIG, Inspector General Randall Meyer, ODNR Director James Zehringer, the ODNR, Nichols, Sean Logan, Thomas Charles, and Anthony J. Celebrezze III. The suit, filed in U.S. District Court Southern District of Ohio in Columbus asks for $2 million in punitive and compensatory damages for losing their jobs.

The plaintiffs allege, in later motions, that Nichols and Charles “manufactured evidence against them” in the investigative report from the OIG and that Little was a participant in the manufacturing.

The plaintiffs claim also that Charles, Nichols, and Little violated the plaintiff’s fourth amendment right to “be free from malicious prosecution,” and that the trio committed conspiracy to violate the plaintiff’s fourth amendment rights.

In his decision on June 4, Judge Frost established that prosecutors have “absolute immunity from liability under § 1983 when he or she “acts within the scope of [his or her] duties in initiating and pursuing a criminal prosecution.” Adams v. Hanson, 656 F.3d 397, 401 (6th Cir. 2011) (citing Imbler v. Pachtman, 424 U.S. 409, 410 (1976)).

As such, the burden is on the plaintiffs to prove that Little did commit misconduct, and Judge Frost did not believe that the plaintiff’s claims were enough to meet that burden.

Judge Frost notes how the plaintiff’s assertion of Little’s alleged malfeasance did not create a “material question of fact,” which is necessary to determine wrongdoing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

2016 News Democrat